

Fifty years ago, The Judgement of Paris put the world on notice that Napa Valley wines could hold their own against the best European contenders. What followed was a golden era of California wine production, led by Napa and, soon, its neighbor to the west, Sonoma County. The North Bay became home to cult wines, new winemaking styles, innovative blends, generations of armchair experts and a burgeoning adult consumer playland.
Today, the narrative has changed. There’s no shortage of ominous headlines predicting the imminent collapse of the global wine industry. But is the situation really as dire as we’re being told?
Studying the market
Wine Market Council (WMC) is a nonprofit trade association focused on understanding the U.S. wine consumer. Established in 1996, it conducts quantitative and qualitative research into wine consumers’ attitudes, purchasing behavior, preferences and drinking occasions. Members include producers, growers, distributors, importers, retailers, trade associations, universities and industry service providers.
“Our role is to give [our members] a shared, fact-based understanding of how the consumer is changing and where the market may be heading,” says Michelle Egan, president of WMC.
“Even as the overall wine-consuming population has declined, our research reveals encouraging generational and demographic shifts,” she continues. “Millennials have overtaken Baby Boomers as the largest wine-drinking cohort, representing 31% of wine consumers, while Gen Z’s share has grown from 9% to 14% and its wine-drinking frequency has increased. The consumer base is also becoming more diverse and more representative of the broader U.S. population.”
So what are the roadblocks the wine industry faces when targeting these new, often younger, consumers?
A three-step industry
“The wine industry is going through a period of real change, and I actually think that creates an opportunity,” says Karissa Kruse, CEO of Sonoma County Winegrowers. “Consumers have more choices than ever, younger consumers engage with brands differently, and the traditional rules around when, where and how people drink wine are changing.
“For Sonoma County, that means we have to meet consumers where they are. We need to make wine more approachable, create experiences people want to be part of, embrace new ways of reaching consumers and give them a reason to care about where their wine comes from and who’s behind it,” she continues. “We also need to do a better job connecting wine to food, travel, sports, culture and the occasions where people are already gathering. Wine should be part of people’s lives, not something that feels complicated or intimidating.”
Gianna Fugazi is a winemaker and industry consultant. “I believe community is the only way we’ll be able to continue growing this industry,” she says. “Because the consumer wants community. They want transparency. They want to know that, ‘This wine was made by someone who cares.’ Why else would they spend their money on that product?”
The daughter of a farmer, Fugazi’s many wine industry hats include positions in both production and retail, and her opinions reflect that broad base of experience. “It’s a three-step industry,” she says. “You have a grower, a maker and a consumer. We don’t focus on the whole picture as much as we pay attention to one bucket at a time.”
Instead, she counsels, it’s time to recognize how the pieces fit together—and work to smooth the transitions. “My fear is that we’re still holding on to this idea of what the industry should be,” she says. “And we’re going to destroy ourselves from the inside before we can make the necessary changes for the [next wave of] consumers.”
Christina Tognetti is director of marketing and operations for Tognetti Family Wines, a boutique, family-owned label based in Los Carneros. “As a small family winery, we have to be very thoughtful about what we produce and how we grow,” she says. “We’re seeing consumers become more selective about where they spend their money and increasingly interested in authentic experiences and the story behind what they’re drinking. For us, that means staying intentionally small, focusing on quality and finding more ways to bring people directly to our family vineyard and connect them with where the wine begins.”
Steady on
For some producers, it remains “business as usual.” Nick Skinner works in operations at Joseph Cellars in Calistoga, though, he laughs, “With only eight employees, we all do everything.”
The winery’s first vintage was 2008, and “some club members have been with us since then,” he says. “Our mission is to produce what our customers are liking, so market headwinds don’t affect us as much.”
In late August, the 2026 harvest was already underway. “About a week early, give or take,” says Skinner. And though yields were down by as much as 20 to 30%, “it’s not outside the expected fluctuations.”
Between its 40-acre estate (spanning Calistoga and Diamond Mountain District AVA) and contracted fruit from Napa and Sonoma counties, Joseph Cellars produces 24 wines annually for 10,000 total case production. “All of our wine is allocated or saved as part of our library programs, so fruit surplus isn’t an issue for us,” says Skinner.
By carving a niche for itself among wine lovers aged 30+ across the country, and consistently producing the varieties and styles those consumers want, Joseph Cellars is navigating the industry turmoil quite nicely, thankyouverymuch.
“Our owners, Joe and Nicole Bartholomew, are doing what they love,” says Skinner. “They’re passionate about wine and optimistic about the future. We’re all doing what we love, and [for us] that’s the best path forward.”
A family affair
Echoing Skinner, Tognetti says, “Like most small family wineries, we all wear a lot of hats. My role touches nearly every part of the business, from marketing and hospitality to DTC, events and day-to-day operations.”
The Tognetti family has been farming on their property since the 1960s, and introduced winegrapes in 1980 with the bulk of fruit contracted to Schramsberg for sparkling wine production. In 2010, three generations came together to start their own winery.
The long-term relationship with the Napa sparkling house creates a buffer for crop fluctuations, says Tognetti. “We’re very fortunate to have had a relationship with Schramsberg for more than 30 years. The majority of our Chardonnay is sold to them for sparkling wine production, and we retain a small portion for our own Tognetti Family Winery wines. That partnership has provided tremendous consistency for our family vineyard over the years.”
In an era of market and climate fluctuations, consistency can be a godsend. Take, for example, this year’s harvest, which Togentti calls “exceptionally early.”
“We started harvesting on August 1—the earliest date ever—and completed picking within three days. Harvest was wrapped up within the week.” What’s more, she continues, “We were down approximately 25% from recent years, harvesting around 70 tons compared with roughly 95 tons. Depending on vineyard replanting and how much acreage is in full production, our tonnage can range from roughly 95 to 130 tons.”
As climate change continues to affect all farming sectors, Tognetti stresses the importance of a “boots-on-the-ground” approach. “The biggest thing we’re noticing is how much less predictable each growing season can be. This year is a perfect example: a warmer-than-normal winter followed by unusually warm conditions in March led to early bud break and accelerated the start of the growing season,” she says. “It really reinforces how much we have to respond to what’s happening in the vineyard each season rather than relying on a traditional calendar.”
Consumer transparency
Much has been made about younger generations seeking authenticity and transparency in their purchases, and the wine industry is not immune to these trends.
Cue the celebrity-owned wine brands: who better to introduce the next generation to the pleasures of wine than an already-known and trusted personality. Performers such as Alecia Moore (aka P!nk), John Legend and Cameron Diaz, among many others, have all thrown their hats in the ring looking for wine industry success. Influencers are also making headway.
“The wine industry is going through a phase like the cosmetic industry did not too long ago,” says Fugazi, who works as general manager for Taft Street Winery’s custom crush program. “Influencers came in and made their own products, because consumers stopped trusting the ingredients and processes of major brands.”
“Consumers have more choices than ever,” agrees Tognetti, “and wineries can’t necessarily rely on the same models that worked in the past. There’s a real opportunity in being personal, transparent and connected to the land. Being able to welcome people here, share [our] history and let them experience the vineyard firsthand makes me very optimistic about what the next generation of our family business can look like.”
Informed choices
WMC’s Egan adds another layer of intrigue. “Younger consumers are more likely to drink across beverage categories and want clearer information about flavor, ingredients, sugar and alcohol content. They show strong interest in sparkling wine, rosé and varied flavor profiles, but taste uncertainty can discourage purchases. Clearer descriptions, greater transparency and more approachable communication can reduce those barriers.”
“If the wine industry really thinks that next gen is the consumer they need to focus on, then we need to do more to figure out what information they want to make a decision to buy wine,” says Fugazi. “We have to look at our industry: Is it currently structured for people to come to it out of curiosity and information gathering? Or, is it structured in a way that we’re telling them ‘This is what you will have and experience’?
“New consumers value full transparency, and the only place I see doing that right now is Europe, which requires all wines that are made or sold there to carry a QR system ingredient label. Wine needs to be approachable and easy to self-educate.”
Fugazi believes instituting a similar program here “could create a level playing field for consumers to make decisions based on product—and maybe put some value to the price point. If you have a wine with a lot of added ingredients in it, versus a wine that has just one or two, you can start to see why one is more expensive.”
“Wine has been part of human culture for thousands of years,” says SCW’s Kruse. “I don’t think people are going to stop enjoying wine. Our job is to evolve with the consumer and continue giving the next generation reasons to choose it.”
***